Of course, the scene has some striking differences from the one in the original novel. Why he didn't had a lot to do with honor and oaths and just seemed a little cringey and, at the very least, lacking in foresight. While Aragorn used them to save Minas Tirith from attack, he could've continued to use them to destroy Sauron's forces at the end of The Return of the King. So the choice not to have the eagles be more integral to the plot was actually dramatically intelligent.Ī similar issue arises when discussing the Army of the Dead's involvement in the War of the Ring. Had the eagles flown Frodo to Mordor, the story would've lost much of its meaning and entertainment value. Related: The Real Reason The Of 'Lord Of The Rings: The Two Towers' Was Changedīut there is one element of this argument that fans tend to agree with. Regardless, fans can and do argue this issue endlessly. Of course, the eagles didn't have too much of a problem doing away with the Wraiths on Wings at the Battle of the Black Gate. They say that Frodo and the eagles would've been too out in the open for Sauron's forces to take down. The most dedicated Tolkien fans are quick to defend what so many claim was an error on both the part of Tolkien and Peter Jackson. While not exactly a scene, many fans of both the movies and the books claim that the giant eagles could have flown Frodo and the ring all the way to Mount Doom, avoiding most of the conflict that ensued in the story. One of the most notable is the 'eagles plot hole'. Of course, some of these aspects were also present in the books. The Strange Story Elements That Have Raised Eyebrowsīefore we get to what fans deem 'the worst' scene in The Lord of the Rings Trilogy, we would be failing you if we didn't discuss some of the most criticized moments from the series.
![lotr two towers game behind the scenes lotr two towers game behind the scenes](https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/DoMAAOSw9rBc22pS/s-l300.jpg)
While there are a couple of scenes fans have complained about, there's no doubt one is easily the worst.
![lotr two towers game behind the scenes lotr two towers game behind the scenes](https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/ZEVgjojZR2F4YqnvacPCER.jpg)
Tolkien's masterful work doesn't mean they like ALL of it.
![lotr two towers game behind the scenes lotr two towers game behind the scenes](https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/lotr/images/1/19/Trolls.jpg)
But just because the vast majority of LOTR fans adore the three feature film adaptations of J.R.R. Of course, that means there are very few terrible moments in The Fellowship of the Ring, The Two Towers, and in the multiple Academy Award-winning The Return of the King. And while there are many reasons why that is, people just can't get over that fact due to the sheer brilliance of Peter's Lord of the Rings Trilogy. After all, the unwavering consensus on those movies is that they just downright sucked. There are countless atrocious scenes in Peter Jackson's Hobbit Trilogy.